Bathing in Well Water With Arsenic
by Gene Franks
Is it safe to shower in water that is contaminated with arsenic?
Dr. Kelly A. Reynolds in a December 2016 Water Conditioning and Purificication
article on arsenic got my attention in her beginning paragraph: “Exposure to arsenic via inhalation, ingestion and skin absorption can lead to cancers of the lung, bladder and skin.” I took note because I have been advising our customers for some time that arsenic in well water is mainly a drinking water issue and that there is little or no evidence that exposure to arsenic through bathing in water that is a few parts per billion over the current recommended limit of 10 parts per billion has any serious health consequences. Consequently, when a well water customer calls or writes with an arsenic issue, we usually recommend taking care of the drinking water, which is easy and not too expensive, and forgoing the much more costly, complicated and often unreliable whole house treatments for arsenic.
Arsenic is serious business and I don’t want to get it wrong, so I did some internet research on the topic: does arsenic, in fact, enter the body through the skin and can it be breathed in during showering?
Most authorities who address the issue of the uptake of arsenic through the skin are pretty clear on the issue. Here are some examples:
Unless your arsenic level is over 500 ppb, showering, bathing and other household uses are safe. Arsenic is not easily absorbed through the skin and does not evaporate into the air. — Mass.gov.
(A publication of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs) [Five hundred parts per billion is 50 times the EPA recommended allowable.]
Only a minimal amount of arsenic is absorbed through the skin.– Virginia Dept. of Health.
Arsenic is not easily absorbed through the skin. — Maryland Dept. of Health.
For most people, the largest source of arsenic is in the food we eat. Most foods, including vegetables, fish, and seafood, contain some arsenic. Arsenic in groundwater can enter the body by drinking the water or by eating food cooked in the water. Arsenic does not evaporate into the air and is not easily absorbed through the skin. — Illinois Dept. of Public Health.
Generally speaking, the main routes of contamination for people who are not exposed to arsenic in their work (occupational exposure) are drinking water first, followed by food. Absorption through the skin seems to be minimal, so arsenic exposure through hand washing, laundry, bathing, etc. is not considered to be a problem. — University of Maine.
Neither the National Research Council (1999) or the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (2000), nor the additional literature searches, identified any controlled studies of inorganic arsenic absorption through human skin. New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection.
The statements above are typical. Some sources do note, however, that trivalent arsenic (arsenite) can pass through the skin much more easily than pentavalent arsenic (arsenate). A couple of sources say, in fact, by a factor of as much as 60:
Dermal uptake of arsenic has been underestimated up to now based on low permeability of arsenate. A new study finds that uptake of arsenic as arsenite or dimethylarsinic acid is a factor of 29 and 59 higher than that of arsenate. — Evisa.
[Keep in mind that 29 to 59 times almost nothing can still be almost nothing.]
Trivalent arsenic is well absorbed through the skin and is 60 times more toxic than pentavalent arsenic, which is well absorbed by the gut. Arsine gas is highly toxic.– Patient. (A UK health professionals reference site.)
No source is cited for the “well absorded through the skin” statement and the end-of-sentence footnote links only to the entry page for a pay-to-use website. Although it is not specified, the admonishment seems to be aimed at arsenic poisoning via industrial pollution rather than water.
In spite of Dr. Reynolds’ statement and other occasional dissenting views, I still feel good about my standard recommendation to customers with wells a few ppb over the recommended maximum of arsenic to fix their drinking water and leave the rest alone. As the picture above would suggest, however, if there is arsenic in your water common sense precautions should be taken.
A brief article on how to remove arsenic from water.