Large companies that plan and provide boxcar-size carbon filters for reduction of hard-to-treat items like volatile organics in municipal water treatment plants or in industrial settings are very good at what they do. They have the advantage of a staff of engineers, very extensive water testing, and in most cases, a known flow rate of water they can pretreat as needed.
Residential water treatment is done differently. The main goal is to make the water a lot better most of the time within the limits of practical considerations like space and cost. It is not practical to attempt whole house treatment of difficult contaminants like fluoride or VOCs. Fortunately, in most cases the difficult contaminants are drinking water not whole house issues, and they can in almost every case be removed from drinking water with point of use reverse osmosis or specialty filtration.
Following the strict engineering rules to assure a very high percentage of VOC reduction on municipal water flowing at 14 or 15 gpm would require a catalytic carbon backwashing filter approximately 42″ in diameter, or eight 12″ X 52″ backwashing filters installed in parallel, or seven or eight 4.5″ X 20″ high quality carbon block filters installed in parallel.
The engineering problem is that VOC removal requires roughly 5 times the contact time with the filter media as compared with chlorine treatment. Also, the life of the carbon is much greater for chlorine removal than for VOCs,
In practical terms, for residential sizing, the more carbon the better. Doubling the number of cartridges more than doubles the life expectancy as well as the effectiveness, plus it has an even greater advantage in terms of pressure drop. But there are practical limits to consider, so sizing for residential units is normally done for what happens most of the time, not for what might happen. Just because a home has four bathrooms doesn’t mean that you should size for ten or twelve gallons per minute to supply water for the rare event of four showers taking place at the same time. Exceeding the ideal flow rate of the filter from time to time will produce slightly lower quality water during the overload and shorten the service life of the carbon filter, but it won’t end the world. In all likelihood, the four people showering in the four bathrooms might experience a slight pressure drop but they probably won’t notice that the water has a bit of chlorine or chloramine in it.
